• Orange Buttermilk Chess Pie

    Orange Buttermilk Chess Pie

    A classic Southern custard pie with century-old roots, this pie was made with what was in the cook’s larder:  eggs, butter, milk, sugar, and cornmeal.  We like the sweet/sour orange flavor that our Old Mill Tropical Orange Dip Mix adds to […]

  • Salted Caramel Pumpkin Skillet Pie

    Salted Caramel Pumpkin Skillet Pie

    Best of all worlds:  salted caramel, pumpkin pie, and my cast iron skillet.  It’s all about deliciousness, right?  For me, I’d start with pie and end with pie at this holiday meal.  Salted caramel is my latest dessert obsession, so […]

  • Apple Pie

    Apple Pie

    All-American classic that’s a must-have addition to your recipe files. A little cider vinegar in the filling keeps the filling from tasting too sugary. For pie dough: 3 cups OLD MILL WHITE UNBLEACHED PLAIN FLOUR 2 teaspoons sugar 1 teaspoon baking powder […]

  • Candy Bar Pecan Pie

    Candy Bar Pecan Pie

    We can’t make Old Mill Pecan Pie Mix any better. Or can we? Try adding coconut, chocolate, and/or toffee chips, and you tell us! Ingredients: 1 jar OLD MILL PECAN PIE MIX 1 partially baked 9-inch piecrust 1/2 cups each: […]